• 1 Post
  • 565 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 1st, 2023

help-circle


  • I think it all comes down to implementation. The first-line approach to mental illness that results in, for example, homelessness, should be minimally invasive. Permanent supportive housing, mental health and substance abuse treatment, etc. There is a huge lack of resources for people without the support structure to get their lives back on track if they don’t have friends and family to assist them.

    There are probably cases where institutionalization is warranted, but it should be used sparingly and only in instances where someone represents a danger to themselves and others, and the less invasive support methods have failed. I think the danger here is that the supportive methods are expensive, and historically governments have been unwilling to invest in them. So there’s a danger that institutionalization/incarceration simply becomes the go-to while skipping over a broad range of strategies focused on rehabilitation.






  • My comment was in jest, but there is a reasonable argument that biological organisms are also predictive input/output machines. It’s especially evident in simple organisms, like an amoeba, where some physical or chemical stimulus in the environment triggers a mostly predictable response.

    The argument that human consciousness is fundamentally different - not just that it’s more complex but that at some point the physical determinism of electrical and chemical impulses gives way to an authority that overrides that physical basis, enabling free thought or free will - remains scientifically unsubstantiated. We know of no mechanism by which that could occur.

    And the philosophical arguments aren’t much better - I’ve never seen a theory of dualism articulated in a way that doesn’t invoke ghosts or magic.






  • China disappeared the Panchen Lama, the second-most important religious figure in Tibetan Buddhism, and replaced him with a China-selected puppet.

    But the Panchen Lama is not the successor to the Dalai Lama. The whole point is that the Dalai Lama will be reincarnated when he dies, so his successor isn’t born yet.

    The Dalai Lama recently proclaimed that his successor will be born in the free nations outside China - allowing him to be born, say, among the substantial Tibetan refugee populations in Nepal or India.

    However, it’s a near-certainty that China will select its own successor from a family loyal to the CCP, and from within China-controlled Tibet, while Tibetans outside the country will likely recognize another.